Testamentary Capacity

Website Team Technicians • February 22, 2019

Does a ‘mild cognitive disorder’ make a will invalid?

This question arose in the case of Tandy v Glaskin that was determined by the Supreme Court of Western Australia on the 25th October 2017.


The Facts

Frank Cox married Eunice Cox in 1990.

It was the second marriage for both of them. Frank had two adult children from his first marriage, Eunice had six.

They lived, it seems, happily ever after. Eunice died in 2014, Frank in 2015.

In 2009, Frank was aged 83. He had medical issues. In September that year he was reviewed by a geriatrician. He was diagnosed with a ‘mild cognitive disorder” (Alzheimer’s). He scored 20 out of a possible 30 on a Mini Mental Examination Test.

Following this diagnosis, Frank and Eunice decided to see a solicitor to prepare wills. They attended upon a solicitor within a week. They saw the solicitor together. At that time the solicitor had about 6 years experience. He had only prepared “about 12 to 15” wills up to that time. He had not seen the geriatrician’s report. There was nothing that led him to suspect that Frank might not have capacity. The wills themselves were perfectly straightforward. Frank left his estate to Eunice (if she survived him) and to divide everything between all their children if they did not. Eunice’s will was the same. There were, three slight differences between their wills: Frank appointed a different substitute executor (his daughter), gave a gift of $5,000 to a grandchild and had different burial directions than Eunice.

In the years following the making of the wills, Frank’s medical condition continued to deteriorate (as is the nature of Alzheimer’s disease. After Eunice died he went into a nursing home.

Although Frank and Eunice had enjoyed an happy second marriage, tensions had arisen between their respective groups of children. Their were proceedings in the State Administrative Tribunal and attempts to manage Frank’s affairs through an Enduring Power of Attorney.

If Frank was found not to have capacity when he made his will, then he would have died intestate and his estate would be divided between his two children (there being no earlier will). That, of course would have been a good result for his two children but not so much for Eunice’s six children, particularly since Eunice had left all her estate to Frank.

After Frank’s death, his daughter lodged a caveat at the probate office to stop a grant of probate being made. The Executor named in Frank’s will (interestingly one of Eunice’s children) had to commence proceedings to ‘prove the will in solemn form’.

Relevant Law

Order 73 rule 15 of the Supreme Court Rules provides for a specific procedure whereby a person can object to probate of a will being granted by indicating that they only intend to cross examine witnesses (as distinct from calling their own witnesses). If they adopt this procedure (and the court pronounces for the validity of the will) then they will not be liable to pay the estates costs of proving the will.

Although the solicitor who prepared the will had no recollection of his meeting with Mr & Mrs Cox, he had seem them both for forty minutes. He had prepared drafts that he had posted to them. When they cam back (two days later) to sign the wills, he had read them over to them before they both signed them.

The geriatrician gave evidence that the poor result on the MME test would not preclude Frank from having the necessary capacity to make a will.

The Decision

The court found that Frank did have capacity. Although the objector did not have to pay the estates costs, she nevertheless had to pay her own.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized on October 27, 2017.

Close-up of a probate sign on a stack of papers and a wooden gavel.
July 21, 2026
How long do probates in Perth take? Learn the WA Supreme Court timeline, common delays, and capped-fee help from Biddulph & Turley. Call now on 08 9398 5533.
Gavel on a judge’s bench with a Supreme Court sign in the background
June 4, 2026
Loved one died before signing their will? A WA Supreme Court decision shows an unsigned draft can still go to probate. Call Biddulph & Turley.
Gavel resting on a “Living Will” document in dim light
May 29, 2026
Will changed late in life under pressure? Learn the grounds to challenge a will in WA and why you must act before probate. Call Biddulph & Turley.
Will Contest book beside a gavel, scales, and gold pen on a desk
May 29, 2026
Brother contesting the will? Learn your rights as a beneficiary under the Family Provision Act in WA and how to respond. Call Biddulph & Turley.
May 29, 2026
Received a Family Provision Act claim as executor? Learn why to hold off distributing the estate and how to protect yourself. Call Biddulph & Turley.
Man standing by a window in a light checkered shirt, looking out with his reflection visible in the glass
May 29, 2026
Father left everything to a new partner? Learn how Family Provision Act claims work in WA and the six month time limit. Call Biddulph & Turley today.
September 22, 2025
Case Summary: When a Note Isn’t a Will Imagine this scenario: After a loved one passes away, a note is discovered—perhaps on their phone, in a drawer, or scribbled on a piece of paper. The note sets out some wishes about who should inherit their assets. Family members hope this note will be accepted as the person’s will. But when the matter goes to court, the judge decides the note is not a valid will. This situation is more common than many realize. In a recent case, a note titled “Last Will” was found on the deceased’s phone. While it expressed some intentions about distributing the estate, the court refused to accept it as an “informal will.” Why? In the case of Gallotti v Galotti-Brown [2025] WASC 384 a handwritten ‘amendment’ was written on a duly executed will. Was this amendment part of the will? Why the Note Was Not Accepted Australian law (and the law in many other places) allows courts to accept a document as an “informal will” even if it doesn’t meet all the usual requirements (like being signed and witnessed). But the court must be convinced of three things: There is a document. The document sets out the person’s testamentary intentions (what they want to happen to their property after death). Most importantly: The person intended the document to operate as their will. In the case above, the court found that the note was more of a draft or a statement of wishes—not a final, operative will. There was no evidence the deceased intended the note to be their last will and testament. The absence of a signature, witnesses, or any indication that the note was meant to be final all counted against it. The Dangers of Informal Wills Relying on informal documents—like notes, emails, or unsent text messages—to express your final wishes is risky. Here’s why: Uncertainty: Courts may not accept the document, leaving your estate to be distributed according to the law, not your wishes. Family Disputes: Ambiguous or informal documents can lead to costly and stressful legal battles among loved ones. Delay and Expense: Proving an informal will is often more complicated, time-consuming, and expensive than preparing a formal will. How to Protect Your Wishes Make a Formal Will: The safest way to ensure your wishes are followed is to make a formal will, properly signed and witnessed. Review Regularly: Update your will as your circumstances change. Seek Legal Advice: A qualified lawyer can help you avoid pitfalls and ensure your will is valid. Don’t leave your legacy to chance. A simple note may not be enough—take the time to make a proper will and give your loved ones certainty and peace of mind.
Close-up of a hand holding a pen.
August 21, 2025
For expert advice on updating wills in Perth, contact Biddulph and Turley today. Visit our website to learn more.
Smiling female lawyer and senior couple going through will
June 25, 2025
Discover how to choose the right executor for your will in Perth, WA. Click here for essential tips and guidance from the experts at Biddulph & Turley.
June 11, 2025
In recent years, the rise of technology has made it easier than ever to create, store, and even amend important documents like wills. Many people assume they can simply jot down their wishes on their phone or leave a note in a digital app, believing this to be sufficient for estate planning. However, legal cases such as Peek v Wheatley [2025] NSWSC 554 highlight the dangers of informal, unprofessional will-making—especially when using a device like an iPhone. The Case at a Glance In Peek v Wheatley, the court examined whether a note found on the late Colin Peek’s iPhone could be considered a valid informal will under the NSW Succession Act 2006. The note, titled ‘Last Will of Colin L. Peek,’ was discovered after his death, and it appeared to specify how his estate should be distributed—primarily passing significant assets to a friend and executor, Mr Wheatley. However, the court faced the challenge of determining whether this digital note truly represented Colin’s testamentary intention—that is, whether it was his clear, deliberate wish to dispose of his estate as stated, with the intention for it to have immediate legal effect. When Will a Document Be Accepted as an Informal Will? In most Australian States, a document that does not meet the formal requirements of a will (such as being signed and witnessed) can sometimes still be accepted as a valid "informal will" if certain criteria are met. The key questions are: Did the deceased intend the document to operate as a will? Was the document clearly intended to dispose of the estate? Did the document demonstrate a genuine testamentary intention? In Peek v Wheatley, the court examined whether the note on the iPhone was created with the intention for it to serve as the deceased’s final testament. The court recognized that while the note contained the deceased’s wishes, it was unclear whether the document was intended to take effect, without more (that is without the will making doing anything else). It was possibly a “working document” or a ‘dry run’ that might be amended later by the will maker or simply a document that he intended to pass on to his solicitor to prepare a will based upon it. The Pitfalls of Informal, Digital Wills This case underscores why relying on informal methods—such as notes on a smartphone—is perilous: Lack of Formalities: A valid will typically requires signatures, witnesses, and clear language. Digital notes often lack these formalities, making their validity uncertain. Ambiguity of Intent: A casual note or message may not conclusively demonstrate the testator’s intention for the document to be their final will, especially if created in a moment of emotion or without legal advice. Potential for Disputes: Informal documents are more easily challenged, leading to costly and time-consuming court disputes, as seen in this case. Risk of Misinterpretation: Digital notes can be vague or incomplete, and their meaning can be misinterpreted, especially if they are not drafted with legal precision. Why You Should Have a Lawyer Prepare a Formal Will The Peek v Wheatley case exemplifies the importance of engaging a qualified lawyer to draft your will. A lawyer ensures that your testamentary wishes are clearly articulated, legally valid, and less susceptible to challenges. They will: Use precise language to avoid ambiguity Follow all legal formalities (signatures, witnesses) Provide advice on estate planning tailored to your circumstances Minimize the risk of intestacy or disputes after death Final Thoughts While it might seem convenient to jot down a quick note on your iPhone or leave a casual message, this approach is fraught with legal uncertainty. The law prefers formal, properly executed documents to ensure your wishes are respected and to minimize disputes among your loved ones.  If you want your estate to be distributed according to your wishes, consult a qualified estate planning lawyer. They will craft a robust, legally sound will that stands up in court and provides peace of mind for you and your family. Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For personalised estate planning assistance, please contact a qualified lawyer. Would you like me to help you draft a tailored legal will or provide further information?